Undoing Toxic: Relationships Are Revealed in Real Time

Welcome back to the Undoing Toxic Blog. Don’t forget to subscribe and never miss another blog update.

Lately, I have been reflecting on three thoughts I saved in my phone:

“We truly get to know people by the nature of the relationship and proximity.”

“You can’t hurt me and expect the same version of me.”

“We build relationships incrementally.”

These quotes continue to feel relevant in a dating culture where many people are not only searching for connection, but also trying to make sense of confusion, inconsistency, and emotional unavailability. Relationships are not built through chemistry alone, clever words, titles, or potential. They are built and revealed through lived experience.

Sometimes the hardest part of modern dating is not rejection. It is the lack of clarity. Many people can tolerate an honest conversation about incompatibility, changing feelings, or wanting different things. What becomes painful is when disappearing replaces communication. You wake up and notice their photo is gone from WhatsApp, “Add Friend” appears on Facebook, or their Instagram page can no longer be found. For a moment, you wonder if something happened to them. Then reality sets in: they are fine. They simply chose avoidance over transparency. Their world kept moving, just without the dignity of informing you. That kind of ending often hurts more than the ending itself because it can trigger confusion, self-doubt, and abandonment wounds.

Proximity Reveals What Distance Can Hide

Sometimes we think we know someone because we like them, admire them, or had a few good conversations. But truthfully, we often get to know people through the nature of the relationship and the closeness required within it.

Friendships reveal themselves through consistency, reciprocity, and presence over time. Romantic relationships reveal themselves through communication, emotional safety, conflict repair, and reliability. Family relationships reveal themselves through boundaries, accountability, and how people respond when old patterns are challenged.

Distance can hide a lot, while proximity reveals more. It is one thing to know someone casually. It is another to know them in responsibility, disagreement, stress, grief, success, or vulnerability. That is why time matters. Shared experience matters. Observation matters.

We Build Relationships Incrementally

Healthy relationships are rarely built in grand gestures. They are built in small moments repeated over time.

A returned phone call.
Following through on a promise.
Listening without defensiveness.
Respecting a boundary.
Checking in consistently.
Repairing after conflict.
Showing care in ordinary moments.

Trust is often less about intensity and more about repetition.

Many people want the closeness of deep relationships without understanding that depth is built gradually. We build relationships incrementally, one interaction at a time. “Rome was not built in a day.”This applies to relationships, too.

Because of the variable experiences and horror stories, there is a push for so many people trying to understand attachment styles. What’s mine? What is theirs? There is a belief that somehow if I know mine, and I know theirs, I can spare myself some trouble, or heartbreak. Sometimes what looks like chemistry is actually anxious attachment activated by inconsistency. Sometimes what feels like independence is avoidant attachment resisting intimacy. Sometimes two people bond not because they are healthy for one another, but because their wounds fit together. Rewiring attachment patterns often means learning to tolerate steadiness if chaos once felt normal. It means recognizing that butterflies are not always intuition; sometimes they are anxiety. It means learning that calm communication, emotional availability, and consistency may feel unfamiliar before they feel safe.

The Dating Landscape Feels Crowded but Unavailable

Many people say they want connection. But, availability and desire are not the same thing. Many people present as available while carrying unfinished business. Some are lonely but not healed. Some are still emotionally attached to an ex. Some are in relationships or marriages while looking out the window for novelty. Some want companionship but not accountability. Some want attention but not responsibility. This is why dating can feel like meeting people’s unresolved chapters rather than meeting people who are truly ready for something new.

Some people are lonely but not healed.
Interested but not intentional.
Charming but not consistent.
Attached elsewhere but window shopping.
Still grieving someone while pursuing someone new.
In relationships while searching for excitement outside of them.
Married but emotionally elsewhere.
Single but deeply unavailable.

No one’s story is always as straight as they present it.

Sometimes the profile says “ready.”
But the nervous system says chaos.
The behavior says unfinished.
The patterns say avoidant.
The choices say still entangled.

This is why dating can feel exhausting. You are often meeting their unprocessed grief, habits, avoidance, and relational history.

When someone has done the work: spent time single, reflected, healed, maybe even went to therapy, strengthened boundaries, and built a full life…it can feel especially discouraging to keep attracting projects! You may meet people who admire your stability but cannot offer their own, people who want nurturing but resist growth, or people who enjoy access to your peace while bringing confusion into your life. This can create the false belief that something is wrong with you. Often, what has changed is not that you attract different people immediately, but that you recognize misalignment sooner. Healing does not magically remove unhealthy options from the dating pool. It helps you identify them faster.

That is where red flags matter. Red flags are not about creating paranoia or expecting perfection. They are cues that deserve attention. Chronic inconsistency, defensiveness, secrecy, disrespect toward boundaries, contempt for former partners, love bombing, disappearing acts, emotional hot-and-cold behavior, or only showing up when convenient are not things to romanticize. Neither is breadcrumbing: the pattern of giving just enough attention, flirtation, or contact to keep someone interested without offering genuine commitment or movement. Breadcrumbing thrives on hope. It keeps people emotionally invested in crumbs while withholding the meal. Many people stay longer than they should because intermittent attention can feel intoxicating, especially when old wounds are involved.

There was also a period where nearly every difficult person was being labeled a narcissist. As a therapist, this was quite exhausting. While narcissistic traits do exist and true narcissistic pathology is real, not every selfish, immature, avoidant, dishonest, or inconsistent person is a narcissist. Sometimes people are simply emotionally underdeveloped, entitled, conflict-avoidant, compulsive, insecure, or unwilling to do the work relationships require. Overusing labels can distract us from the more important question: regardless of what they are called, how do they treat people, and is that treatment acceptable to you?

I recently listened to an Esther Perel podcast discussing chronic philanderers. Chronic philanderers are defined as “serial cheaters, are individuals who repeatedly and consistently engage in sexual or emotional infidelity within a committed, monogamous relationship. Unlike a one-time affair, chronic philandering is a recurring, deeply ingrained pattern of behavior rather than an isolated lapse in judgment.”

Repeated cheating isn’t always because the partner lacks something. Chronic infidelity usually comes from the cheater’s inner issues: craving novelty or validation, avoiding vulnerability, fearing aging, feeling empty, or being unable to handle close intimacy. They chase excitement but can’t sustain deep connection. Remembering this can help; you weren’t necessarily lacking; their repeated betrayal often reflects their own unresolved problems.

How Did Healthy Couples Find Each Other?

Many people ask: How did the people who found their person do it without all this drama?

Truthfully?

Some met healthy people early.
Some got lucky timing.
Some had to go through many wrong fits first.
Some found each other after deep healing seasons and loss.
Some met through community, faith spaces, work, hobbies, mutual friends, or everyday life.
Some used apps successfully.
Some almost missed each other entirely.

There is no single formula.

But healthy love usually shares a few traits:

Mutual effort.
Consistency.
Clear communication.
Emotional availability.
Respect.
Shared values.
Repair when conflict happens.
Peace more than confusion.

Healthy love is often quieter than toxic chemistry. It may feel less dramatic because it is safer.

Pacing Is Almost Everything

One of the healthiest things you can do is slow down.

Do not let charm outrun character. Charm is a warm first impression; character is the steady behavior that follows. A person who dazzles you in a week may still disappoint you in a year. Give time and observation the space to reveal who someone actually is.

Do not let attraction outrun observation. Attraction narrows attention; observation widens it. Notice not only how someone makes you feel in certain moments, but how they behave in ordinary interactions. Attraction without scrutiny is risk disguised as romance.

Do not let loneliness outrun discernment. Loneliness pushes us toward quick fixes and premature commitments. Discernment asks clearer questions: Do I feel safe? Do we handle conflict with care? Am I seen and respected? Choosing connection to avoid solitude can cost you the kind of relationship that truly sustains.

Do not let potential outrun evidence. “Could be” is not the same as “is.” Potential is worth hope; evidence is worth trust. Look for patterns that show the person is already capable of the kindness, reliability, and integrity you want, not just promising to grow into them someday.

When intimacy moves faster than trust, we can mistake momentum for security. We can confuse intensity for compatibility, fast vulnerability for safety, and attraction for alignment. A rapid escalation can create a feeling of closeness without the grounding elements that make closeness safe and durable. Pause and ask whether the pace is mutual, mindful, and supported by consistent actions.

Something moving quickly does not always mean it is moving wisely. Speed can amplify blind spots. It can hide avoidance of important conversations, bypass testing of boundaries, and short-circuit the natural ways people show who they are over time.

People reveal themselves through patterns, not promises. Promises are statements about intention; patterns are records of behavior. Track the rhythms of someone’s life:

• Watch how they handle disappointment. Do they take responsibility, communicate, and repair, or do they blame, withdraw, or escalate?

• Watch how they speak of their past. Do they reflect on their part in the story, or is everyone else to blame? Their language reveals how they process conflict and accountability.

• Watch how they respond to boundaries. Do they respect limits, or do they minimize, guilt, or pressure you to change them? Respect for boundaries signals capacity for mutual care.

• Watch whether their words and life align. Consistency between what they say and what they do is the clearest indicator of reliability.

• Watch whether consistency exists when novelty fades. When the initial excitement subsides, does their kindness, curiosity, and consideration remain?

Time is not wasting your chances. Moving slowly isn’t forfeiting a connection; it’s protecting it. Time allows observation, testing, and the slow accrual of trust. It lets you see whether kind gestures are habitual or performative, whether crisis brings clarity or chaos, and whether comfort and commitment endure beyond the thrill.

Time is protecting your future. Slowing down preserves your capacity to choose from a place of clarity rather than urgency. It helps ensure that the person you build with now is truly aligned with the life you want later. Choose the pace that lets you gather evidence, honor your needs, and protect your heart.

If you feel discouraged, it makes sense. Many people are tired of sorting through mixed signals, unfinished people, and modern avoidance. But a difficult landscape does not mean healthy love is unavailable. It may mean discernment is more necessary than ever. Your standards may narrow the field, but that is not punishment, it is protection.

The goal is not to find just anyone. It is to find someone capable of honesty, reciprocity, consistency, and emotional presence. Until then, keep rewiring what once felt familiar but unhealthy. Keep honoring red flags instead of explaining them away. Keep noticing when crumbs are being offered in place of commitment. Keep refusing to confuse chaos with passion. And remember: takers often keep taking, so givers must know when to stop giving. Relationships are not proven by promises or profiles. They are revealed in real time.

Thank you for reading.

Let’s connect. Email me: moniqueevanstherapy@gmail.com

Accepting individual, couples, and family clients (self-pay and select insurance via headway.co- Monique Evans, LCSW)

For social work clinicians, I also offer clinical consultation meetings (Not to be confused with clinical supervision for licensure hours) at any level of practice.

Book me as your mental health presenter for speaking engagements, podcasts, panels, and presentations.

Disclaimer:

The intention for using social media for social workers and other mental health professionals is for marketing, education, advocacy, thought leadership, and providing content in a technologically changing field. We want to do this while making potential therapy-seekers aware of the risks and benefits of engagement on social media and Internet where mental health professionals are present. A therapeutic relationship is a professional relationship and in today's technological climate, a social media presence or following your therapist on social media is not to be confused with a relationship outside of therapy. Ethical, professional, and therapeutic boundaries must be followed and honored. 

• A counseling social media page or blog is not psychotherapy, a replacement for a therapeutic relationship, or substitute for mental health and medical care. A social media presence as a counseling professional is not seeking an endorsement, request, or rating from past or current clients. No social media posts or blog should be considered professional advice. The information contained in posts is general information for educational purposes only.

• Be mindful of sharing personal details or details or others if you choose to comment.

• Please consult your physician or mental health provider regarding advice or support for your health and wellbeing. 

• If you or someone you know is experiencing a medical and/or psychiatric mental health crisis and requires assistance, please call 911 emergency services and/or go to your nearest emergency room (ED) department.

• 988- National Suicide Prevention Hotline (24 hours a day, 7 days a week)

• Safe Horizon 24-hour Hotlines (se habla español):

  • Domestic violence victims: 800-621-HOPE (4673)